5

Every proper maximal subgroup of a $p$-group $P$ is normal and has index $p$.

I tried to search online by I can't get a complete proof.

Take $M$ to be maximal and $Z$ to be central subgroup of order $p$.

Case 1: $Z\subset M$
We prove by induction on $|P|$.
For the base case, $|P|=p$.
There is no maximal subgroup in $P$, hence the result holds

Assume that the result holds for all $p$-group $Q$ with $|Q|<|P|$
Note that $|Z|>1$. Hence $|P/Z|<|P|$.
Suppose that $M/Z$ is not a maximal subgroup of $P/Z$.
Then there exists a subgroup $H$ such that $M/Z\subset H/Z \subset P/Z$.
But this also implies that $M\subset H \subset P$.
This means that $M$ is not maximal, a contradiction.
Hence $M/Z$ is a maximal subgroup of $P/Z$.
By induction hypothesis, $M/Z$ has index $p$ and $M/Z\trianglelefteq P/Z$.
First, we can conclude that $M \trianglelefteq P$.
Second, note that $[P/Z:M/Z]=p$. Hence $[P:M]=p$.

Case 2: $Z\not\subset M$
This implies that $P=ZM$.
Let $p=zm\in P$ where $z\in Z$ and $m\in M$.
Clearly, $p^{-1}Mp=M$. So we see that $M \trianglelefteq P$.
But for this case, I have no idea on how to prove $M$ has index $p$.

Wang Kah Lun
  • 10,240
  • Is $P$ assumed finite? –  Apr 29 '16 at 01:45
  • I'm not sure about it, but I don't think induction on prime numbers can be done... If you know you can, can you explain me why? – eti902 Apr 29 '16 at 01:47
  • @Bungo Yes I assume that it is finite. – Wang Kah Lun Apr 29 '16 at 01:47
  • And in the case 2, M has index p because of the definition of p-group and beacause of the rule of cardinality and subgroup (the order of any subgroup always divide the order of the group) – eti902 Apr 29 '16 at 01:51

2 Answers2

2

Theorem 1: Every finite $p$-group is nilpotent.
Proof: see here.

Theorem 2: A finite group is nilpotent if and only if all its maximal proper subgroup are normal.
Proof: see here.

Theorem 3: A proper normal maximal subgroup of a finite group has prime index.
Proof: see here.

Corollary: Every proper maximal subgroup of a $p$-group is normal and has index $p$.

1

I think the proof by induction is a good idea. But perhaps you should induct on the exponent of the group. So, if $|P|=p^1,$ then the problem holds. Assume true for $|P|=p^n,$ then for $|P|=p^{n+1},$ we have that the center of $P$ (which we can call $Z$) is non-trivial (and also a $p$ group) so $Z$ contains an element of order $p$, call it $x$. But since $Z$ is characteristic and abelion, then the group $X=<x>$ is normal in $P$. Thus $|P/X|=p^{n-1}.$ So any maximal subgroup of the quotient group is normal by the inductive hypothesis. I think from here the rest of the proof is pretty straight forward.