This question is in the spirit of the question "Nice examples of groups which are not obviously groups".
There are many impressive finiteness results in mathematics. For example:
- The finiteness of $\text{Gal}(\overline{\mathbf R}/\mathbf R)$;
- The finite-generatedness of homotopy groups of spheres;
- The finiteness of the set of smooth structures on the $n$-sphere, for $n\neq 4$;
- The conjectured finiteness of Shavarevich-Tate groups;
- The finite-generatedness of Mordell-Weil groups;
- The finiteness of class numbers;
- The finiteness of the set of rational points on a curve $X/\mathbf Q$ when the genus $X>1$...
So, what are the nicest examples of finite sets which are not obviously finite?