1

$G$ is a cyclic group. the order of $G$ is $n$ ($|G|=n$). $m\mid n$, I have to prove that there is $b\in G$ that $ord(b)=m$.

Know, here is one part of the proof:

if $m\mid n$ that means that $n=mk$. Lets mark: $$b=a^k$$ then: $$b^m=(a^k)^m=a^n=e\Rightarrow ord(b)=m$$

Now I need to prove that $m$ is minimal. How I'm prove this?

Thank you!

amWhy
  • 209,954
CS1
  • 2,047

1 Answers1

3

Answer to Original Post, Before Edit:

The theorem you are trying to prove, as stated, is not true. The converse of Lagrange's Theorem does not, in general, hold.

For example, take $A_4$, the alternating group of $S_4$. $\;|A_4| = 12$, and clearly, $\;6\mid 12.\;$ However, there is no subgroup of order $6$ in $A_4$, and hence, no element $b\in A_4$ whose order is $6$.

So Lagrange holds here, and the corresponding Corollary that for every element $b\in A_4$, the order of $b$ divides the order of $A_4$ is of course true, but it does not follow that if $m$ divides the order of a group, then there is an element of order $m$.

With limitations, the theorem is true. Specifically,

  • if $G$ is a finite abelian group, or

  • if the order of $G$ is a power of a prime, or

  • if $G$ is solvable,

then the statement is true.


After edit: Indeed, this is true for the finite cyclic group $G$.

Suggestion about the initial part of your proof: Make sure you make explicit that, since G is cyclic, it is generated by one element, we'll call $a$. So $\langle a\rangle = G$. Then it follows that there is some element $b \in G$ such that $b = a^k$, where $0\leq k \lt n$.

To show that $m$ is minimal, we can show that if there exists $0\leq s \lt m$ such that $b^s = e$, then $s = 0$. Or else you can assume, for the sake of contradiction, that there exists an $s$, $0\lt s \lt m$ such that $b^s = e$, and obtain a contradiction.

amWhy
  • 209,954