In a proof I do a case split about a set $M \subseteq \Bbb N$. In one case $M$ is finite and it means that there’s some bijection only between n elements of $\Bbb N$ and all the elements of $M$, so $|M| \lt |\Bbb N|$. In the other case M is infinite. Can I now conclude/prove that $|M| = |\Bbb N|$? I have no theory of cardinal numbers available. I still feel it must be provable that there cannot be some set $M \subseteq \Bbb N$ that is infinite but still somehow $|M| \le |\Bbb N|$. (If indeed it was not provable I‘d like to just assume it because it‘s natural because then the proof would formally work, right?)
Asked
Active
Viewed 78 times
0
-
Yes, this is true. – Randall Jun 25 '21 at 02:15
-
Why? Can u give some proof? – Jun 25 '21 at 02:17
-
1It’s probably already on this site, so I don’t wish to duplicate. – Randall Jun 25 '21 at 02:19
-
I have noticed that in your post you're linking to a comment. Is that intentional? Maybe you actually wanted to link to that answer? – Martin Sleziak Jun 25 '21 at 12:49
1 Answers
1
The proof is simple: let
$$a_1=\min(M)$$
$$a_2=\min(M-\{a_1\})$$
$$a_3=\min(M-\{a_1,a_2\})$$
$$\vdots$$
$$a_n=\min(M-\{a_1,a_2,...,a_{n-1}\})$$
$$\vdots$$
Since $M$ is a subset of the natural numbers, you are assured that the minimum is well defined and exists at every step. Also, since $M$ is infinite, this process will never end. Now, does this sequence $a_n$ encompass every element of $M$? Said differently, for all $b\in M$, is there $N\in\mathbb{N}$ such that $a_N=b$? This is obviously true as after $b$ steps we have that $a_b\geq b$. Thus, $b=a_N$ for some $1\leq N\leq b$. Finishing the proof, note that the sequence $a_i$ puts the elements of $M$ into a bijection between the elements of $\mathbb{N}$, which is the definition of countable.

QC_QAOA
- 11,796