I want to find a simple example of a property that looks like it holds for all $n \in \mathbb{N}$, but that does not. I remember reading about one that got in hold for centuries before someone found out a ridiculously big value of $n$ for which the property didn't hold, but I don't remember what the property was.
I'd like if the example property was easy to explain and didn't demand many concepts outside basic knowledge of the natural numbers.
Anything like that?