I need to prove that every permutation $\sigma \in S_n, \sigma \neq id$ can be written as a distinct product of disjoint cycles and don't really know where to start. The statement is totally clear, but I cannot think of an elegant way to proof its correctness.
-
1Then try a non-elegant way and tell us what you got. – José Carlos Santos Oct 18 '17 at 09:32
-
@Arnaud D. It is a good reference indeed. – Jean Marie Oct 18 '17 at 10:16
-
Also related is https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/843691/group-of-permutations-and-disjoint-cycles?rq=1 – Arnaud D. Oct 18 '17 at 10:19
1 Answers
Let $\sigma$ be the permutation, and let $[n]=\{1,2,\ldots,n\}$ be the set that we are considering.
First, choose one element from the set, say $x$, and permute it until you reach $x$ again, and collect every element you reaches. i.e. Formulate the cycle $$C_x=(x\;\sigma(x)\;\sigma^2(x)\ldots\sigma^k(x))$$ And the set $$E_x=\{x,\sigma(x),\sigma^2(x),...,\sigma^k(x)\}$$ Where $\sigma^{k+1}(x)=x$ and $\sigma^r(x)\neq x, \forall r\le k$. Now, $k$ can be found since $[n]$ is finite, and since $\sigma$ is a bijection, if $\sigma^i(x)=\sigma^j(x)$, then $\sigma^{i-j}(x)=\sigma^{j-j}(x)=x$, so all of the $\sigma^d(x)$ are distinct from each other, $\forall d\le k$.
Pick one element, say $1$, then $C_1$ is a cycle. And choose $p\in [n]\setminus E_1$, and find $C_p$ and $E_p$. Since $p\notin E_1$, $E_p\cap E_1=\varnothing$. Continue this until (can be reach since $[n]$ is finite) $[n]$ is exhausted. And multiply all $C_x$s, and we are done.
By the way, $\sigma=\mathrm{id}$ also can be written so, take $(1)(2)(3)\cdots(n)$

- 2,565
-
Although late I have a doubt. If $\sigma =(123)(45)$ is a cycle in $S_5$ then we consider the partition which contains $1$ ,then a partition $E_1$ is $(1,\sigma(1)=2,\sigma^2(1)=3,\sigma^3(1)=3,\sigma^4(1)=2,\sigma^5(1)=3)$. The elements of this cycle are not distinct..Where am I making a mistake? – Antimony Oct 23 '20 at 19:09
-
@smita $\sigma = (123)(45)$ is not a cycle, this permutation has two nontrivial orbits, a cycle has only one nontrivial orbit. $\sigma$ is the product of the two (disjoint) cycles $(123)$ and $(45)$. – Daniel Fischer Dec 25 '20 at 13:14