1

The problem arises from frequency response method (control systems ) and most books try to explain why we replace $'s'$ by $'j\omega'$ in frequency response. So, let me get to the math part; Our system is$$ y(t)=ae^{-j\omega t} +be^{j\omega t}$$ Which is the steady state response.

The input is sinusoid $x(t)=A\sin(wt)$; and thus the output is also a sinusoid. In the Laplace domain, the relation between input($x(s)$) and output ($y(s)$) is $$y(s)=G(s)x(s)$$ where $G(s)$ is the transfer function.now here is my problem, when finding $a$ and $b$ here is what they did. $$a=G(s)\frac{(\omega A)}{(s^{2}+\omega^{2})}(s+j\omega)$$ and $$b=G(s)\frac{(\omega A)}{(s^{2}+\omega^{2})}(s-j\omega)$$ ( I know how this is derived but I don't know the next step which is:-)

When evaluating a and b at $-j\omega$ and $j\omega$ respectively we get; $$a=-A\frac{G(-j\omega)}{2j}$$ $$b=A\frac{G(j\omega)}{2j}$$ So, my question is why did we pick the point $j\omega$ in place of $'s'$ For $b$ and $-j\omega$ For $a$?

$TRIAL$

May be initial conditions....

Socre
  • 559
  • Because frequency response is closely related to Fourier transform and in most cases, the Fourier transform and Laplace transform are related by $s=j\omega$ – polfosol Jan 11 '17 at 08:48
  • And if you are asking why don't we use Fourier transform in the first place, the answer is Laplace transform has simpler form and less complexities – polfosol Jan 11 '17 at 08:49
  • But the paradigm "replace $s$ by $j\omega$" hides many pitfalls, and should no longer be presented to students! A first visible inadequacy is that the domain of integration is not the same ($(0,\infty)$ for Laplace, and ($(-\infty,\infty)$ for Fourier ). Fundamentaly Laplace Transforms deals with causal functions (http://www.personal.soton.ac.uk/jav/soton/HELM/workbooks/workbook_20/20_1_causal_fns.pdf), whereas there is nothing similar for Fourier transforms. – Jean Marie Jan 11 '17 at 09:07
  • @JeanMarie You are right. I have discussed the situation in here – polfosol Jan 11 '17 at 09:56
  • @polfosol ... and there for me :) – Jean Marie Jan 11 '17 at 10:13

0 Answers0