8

Let $a_{1},a_{2},\cdots,a_{N}$ be nonnegative reals, not all $0$. Prove that there exists a sequence $$1=n_{0}<n_{1}<\cdots<n_{k}=N+1$$ of integers such that $$n_{1}a_{n_{0}}+n_{2}a_{n_{1}}+\cdots+n_{k}a_{n_{k-1}}<3(a_{1}+a_{2}+\cdots+a_{N})$$

I need to understand the problem here.

and I fell it is Strange to use probability to can solve it. Can find other methods?

Ali Caglayan
  • 5,726
math110
  • 93,304

1 Answers1

2

This is basically the same argument as the probability approach used in the original solution, but somewhat simplified and hopefully easier to understand.

To help avoid special cases for the $n_i$, let's start by appending zeroes to the list $a_1,\ldots,a_N,0,\ldots,0$ so it gets length $2^k-1\ge N$. We will make a solution to this consisting of $1=n_0<\cdots<n_{k-1}<n_k=2^k$. To solve the original problem, depending on whether $n_{k-1}>N$ or not, replace $n_k$ with $n_k=N+1$, or remove $n_k$ and replace $n_{k-1}$ with $n_{k-1}=N+1$.

We consider all combinations of $n_1\in\{2,3\}$, $n_2\in\{4,5,6,7\}$, etc.: i.e., $n_i\in\{2^i,\ldots,2^{i+1}-1\}$ for $i=1,\ldots,k-1$. This gives us lots of options for the sequence $n_i$.

Next, we average over all combinations of $n_i$. The average value of $n_i$ is $(3\cdot2^i-1)/2<3\cdot2^{i-1}$ while the average value of $a_{n_i}$ is $(a_{2^i}+\cdots a_{2^{i+1}-1})/2^i$. Since $n_i$ and $n_{i+1}$ are chosen independently, this makes the average value of the term $a_{n_i}n_{i+1}$ $$ \text{E}[a_{n_i}n_{i+1}] =\text{E}[a_{n_i}]\cdot\text{E}[n_{i+1}]<3\cdot(a_{2^i}+\cdots+a_{2^{i+1}-1}) $$ which also holds for the term $i=k-1$ as $n_k=2^k<3\cdot 2^{k-1}$.

Adding all the $a_{n_i}n_{i+1}$ terms together then yields $$ \text{E}[a_{n_0}n_1+\cdots+a_{n_{k-1}}n_k] <3\cdot(a_1+\cdots+a_{2^{k}-1}). $$ Since the bound is true for the average, it must be true for at least one of the sequences.