Amortised analysis of a simple loop and 3 operations

Question

I'm trying to figure out amortised analysis of this loop and I can't figure out how to prove that complexity is $O(n \log n)$.

Operation OP(S,X[i]) has complexity O(log|S|) and operations push and pop has constant complexity O(1).

S <- Emptystack
for i=1 to n do
    while (S!=0) and OP(S,X[i]) do
        pop(S)
    od
    push(S,X[i])
od

I would like to proove it using potential function. It would be simple if there were just pop(S) and push(s):

Pot.function represents number of items in stack

C^ PUSH = 1 + |S|+1 - |S| = 2

C^ POP = 1 + |S|-1 - |S| = 0

So the complexity would be linear (O(2n)) = O(n). But I don't know how to compute amortized complexity of OP.

Apply the execution count method. – Raphael Jun 14 '16 at 09:41 — Raphael, Jun 14 '16 at 09:41

score 2 · Answer 1 · answered Jun 14 '16 at 09:07

We can divide the running time into several parts:

Pushes.
Pops.
The first OP performed at every round.
Subsequent OPs performed at every round.

Note that every OP costs $O(\log n)$, that there are at most $n$ pops, and that each "subsequent OP" follows a pop. We conclude that the total running time of pushes and pops is $O(n)$, the total running time of first OPs is $O(n\log n)$ (since there are $n$ rounds), and the total running time of subsequent OPs is $O(n\log n)$ (since there are at most $n$ pops). In total, the running time is $O(n\log n)$.

If you want to use the potential method, try to use a potential of the form $|S| + \log(|S|!)$.

Amortised analysis of a simple loop and 3 operations

1 Answers1