Or at least generate a set of strings that one NFA accepts, so I can feed it into the other NFA. If I do a search through every path of the NFA, will that work? Although that will take a long time.
Asked
Active
Viewed 2,039 times
10
-
No (not to our knowledge, at least). NFA equality is PSPACE-complete. See this discussion. – Shaull Jun 11 '13 at 17:29
-
@Shaull: The OP did not as for an efficient way. – frafl Jun 11 '13 at 17:31
-
@frafl: You are right. I assumed by "will take a long time" that the OP wants an efficient solution. Still, my comment mentions that it's in PSPACE, so it's decidable. – Shaull Jun 11 '13 at 18:03
1 Answers
10
The decision problem is PSPACE-complete as Shaull noted.
However, it turns out that in practice it is often possible to decide NFA equivalence reasonably quickly. Mayr and Clemente (based on experimental evidence) claim that the average-case complexity scales quadratically. Their techniques rely on pruning the underlying labelled transition system via local approximations of trace inclusions.
Just like SAT is NP-complete in a worst-case analysis, yet often turns out surprisingly tractable for real-world instances, it therefore seems likely that NFA equivalence can be decided efficiently for many real-world instances.
- Richard Mayr and Lorenzo Clemente, Advanced automata minimization, POPL 2013, doi:10.1145/2429069.2429079 (preprint)
András Salamon
- 3,462
- 1
- 20
- 35