Pencils seem to have different types:
From what I've seen, there's a few types:
- HB
- 2HB
- B
and so on.
What's the difference between all the different pencils? When do I use one or the other?
Asked
Active
Viewed 2.3k times
2 Answers
21
H and B relate to the hardness or softness of the pencil's graphite. "H" stands for "hard" and "B" stands for "black" with "F" right in the middle between HB and H... though, the source of the lettering seems to be debatable according to Wikipedia - H stands for "Hardtmuth" (the surname of the owner of an art supply company) and B stands for "Budweis", the town the pencil company was relocated to but "hard" and "black" are probably more useful to remember.
A "number 2 pencil" as we (in the US) are often told to use for filling out multiple choice answers on Scantron sheets, is right in the middle, the equivalent of "HB"... though, according to this site, there's no "industry standard" so one company's HB may not be the same as another's. This is also explained in the Wikipedia article linked above, which notes that on some scales, the US equivalent of HB is a #2 pencil, while other manufacturers use the equivalent HB=2½.
As a general explanation of the differences between the grades, pencils.com shows the following image:
As you can see in the image, the higher the H value, the lighter the result but the finer the point, while at the other end, the higher the B value, the darker the blackness of the graphite and wider the point.
This site has some great guidance on what the benefits of each are:
H leads are extremely smudge-resistant and give cleaner lines, making them useful for things such as outlines, technical drawings, light sketches, and even watercolors. Left-handed pencil users can also take advantage of smudge-resistant H leads. On the downside, hard leads tend to be scratchy, especially as you move up the scale.
B leads are smooth to write and draw with. They smudge easily, but are readily erased. They're perfect for pencil drawings as artists can take advantage of the brush-like expressions, especially in the higher B grades. Animators in particular enjoy using 10B over animator paper because it writes like butter, creating nice, quick, heavy lines with no friction.
-
-
But what's the difference between "HB=2" and "HB=2.5" as shown in the OP's image? How come there's more than one kind of HB? – Rand al'Thor May 21 '16 at 21:25
-
@Randal'Thor No clue. The numbers may not even relate to HB... they could be the width of the graphite inside the pencil, for example... I can't see the brand so I don't have a way of doing any additional research... but that's not what the question was asking about. The content of the question only relates to the H or HB or B parts. – Catija May 21 '16 at 22:24
-
Looks like it relates to there being more than one system for classifying the pencil's grade and the note above that not all HB pencils are equal to each other... One system has HB=2 and the other system has HB=2.5 where HB is a Worldwide rating and the 2 or 2.5 is a US-specific system that is where we get the "use a #2 pencil on this test"... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pencil#Grading_and_classification – Catija May 21 '16 at 22:32
-
@Catija I'm using Faber Castell. Since I can't afford all grades, I'm just buying 3 grades. I've already bought HB and 8B and now I need one more: either 4B or 5B. But I can't make a decision. That's why I came here searching a lot of things online. So if you know, is there any big difference between 4B and 5B? Like 5B will break easier than 4B? – Vikas Jul 28 '21 at 08:37
-
1
-
@Catija actually I had almost composed it but not posted. I got some opinions and suggestions in this site's room chat, but still it would have been better if I could get more opinions from more people. So thing is, I didn't post because I feared it might get closed as opinion based. But I have done some research on it. It's just not like a question 'which is better'. So do you think I should post it? – Vikas Jul 28 '21 at 15:25
-
@Vikas The question you want to ask isn't "which is better" it's "what is the difference between the two so that I can make the decision about which makes sense to add to my toolbox" or "Are these two different enough that which I choose will be a big difference in my situation". Talk about how you're planning to use the pencils (style of art, etc) and what you have already - opinion questions aren't always bad if they're thoroughly framed. – Catija Jul 28 '21 at 15:31
-
@Catija yeah, I'll ask it that way only. I've already thought about it. Okay then I'll post it soon. Thanks. – Vikas Jul 28 '21 at 15:40
7
(This answer is partly based on product information from Faber-Castell; thus, it may not be without bias.)
The wood-cased pencil was invented following the discovery of a large graphite deposit in Borrowdale, England in 1564. The substance was so soft and brittle that it required a holder. (Originally, the grey metallic-sheened substance was thought to be a form of lead ore. Hence, the words for ‘pencil’ in several languages literally mean ‘lead pen’. It was not until 1789 that the chemist Carl Wilhelm Scheele proved that graphite and lead sulfide were two different minerals, and the geologist Abraham Gottlob Werner coined the name graphite, which stems from ‘gráphein’, meaning ‘to write’ or ‘to draw’ in Greek.)
When the supply of natural graphite from Borrowdale ran short, the graphite was thinned down with other materials. In 1794, Nicholas-Jaques Conté and Joseph Hardtmuth independently discovered almost at the same time that by mixing graphite with clay it was possible to produce leads with different degrees of hardness, which would preserve the graphite deposits and also accommodate a variety of applications.
The graphite-clay mixing process was improved by Lothar von Faber in 1839. It was at that time that the hardness grade scale was established. Today, the scale encompasses 17 grades of hardness: 8B–B, HB, F, H–7H.
According to Ullmann’s Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemistry, the clay content varies from 15 % in the softest lead to ca. 60 % in the hardest. A mixture of about 2 parts of graphite and 1 part of clay gives the usual HB or 2 1/2 degrees of hardness.
The following image is adapted from product information for the Castell 9000, which is available in 16 degrees of hardness:
The same scale of hardness is used in ISO standards (for example for the determination of film hardness of paints by pencil test; in this test method, calibrated pencils of known hardness are pushed over the film). The hardness scale in use in the United States employs only numbers. The most important grades in the two scales approximately have the following relationship:
- 3B – 1
- 2B – 1 1/2
- B – 2
- HB – 2 1/2
- F – 3
- H – 3 1/2
- 2H – 4
- 3H – 4 1/2
- 4H – 5