-3

Which one is closer to the Earth, Phobos, Deimos or Mars? None of the answers that I find actually answer my question.

2 Answers2

11

To expand on fasterthanlight's excellent answer: on average, Mars is the closest. The reasoning behind this claim perhaps is best illustrated with a (not to scale) picture showing that Mars and a Martian moon are equidistant from the Earth only when they form an isosceles triangle. Hence, for the majority of the orbit, Mars is closer (the red part of the orbit).

enter image description here

Notes:

  1. The same argument holds for both Martian moons.
  2. The orbital plane of each Moon doesn't contain the line segment from Mars to Earth as shown in the cartoon. However, a similar argument holds for any offset.
  3. I define distance from the center of gravity. If you use distance from surfaces, the effect will be greater.
  4. The eccentricity of the Martian moon orbits is very low, so not considered here.
Connor Garcia
  • 16,240
  • 4
  • 43
  • 96
6

It depends on which orbital phase each body is in. In the below (poorly drawn) diagram, Mars is the closest as it is merely a straight line to the Earth. If Phobos is in front of Mars while Deimos is behind it, it is closer, but if both are in front, Deimos is closer. Mars is only the closest when both moons are behind it.

enter image description here

WarpPrime
  • 6,653
  • 1
  • 24
  • 61