1

I'm actually asking about my wife's MacBook Pro which I don't use very often. It's slowed down quite a bit recently and apparently before the update to El Capitan. Programs have started to take a long time to launch but once they have launched actually run fine. After booting up it will take about 45 seconds for Safari to even be usable. Spotlight also lags a lot and can't even keep up with typing, although it responds to 'escape' quickly.

I've watched the system monitor and even when programs are launching the CPU seems to be low with around 90% idle. It has 4GB of RAM and there always seems to be around 1.5Gb free.

I've attached the summary showing the hardware below. It doesn't have an SSD.

I've also run the Apple Hardware Test which took approximately an hour and nothing was reported from it.

From what I've read people have suggested upgrading the memory but since it doesn't seem to be running out of memory I would be surprised if this helped. There's also very little running and nothing user installed that is being launched in the Dock at start up.

Any help would be great and happy to provide any other stats needed.

Model Name: MacBook Pro

  • Model Identifier: MacBookPro9,2
  • Processor Name: Intel Core i5
  • Processor Speed: 2.5 GHz
  • Number of Processors: 1
  • Total Number of Cores: 2
  • L2 Cache (per Core): 256 KB
  • L3 Cache: 3 MB Memory: 4 GB
Allan
  • 101,432
Fraser
  • 141
  • With OS X 10.9 and newer relying on one having an SSD (or so it seems to me), I guess that the slowdown loading the OS or any apps is caused by the use of a regular HDD. This is in line with your statement that once they are loaded, they work fine. – Phoenix Dec 15 '15 at 20:44
  • I'm not sure this is correct since apple currently sell the entry level macbook pro with a HDD. Is there any app to prove that the slow down is due to the HDD? – Fraser Dec 16 '15 at 08:56
  • My comment was purely my own observation on how everything (even other OSs) slow down when loading while using a HDD to load from. Generally, HDDs are slower in reading and writing compared to SSDs. So, when you stated that your MacBook Pro is slow when loading something from the HDD, but is fast thereafter (when app data and app relaunches are done mainly through inactive memory/cache), then my logical assumption is that it is caused by you having a HDD. You could have a look in Activity Monitor to see how much is put through your disk and/or RAM and compare when your computer is slow. – Phoenix Dec 16 '15 at 09:06
  • In my Mac Pro (Early 2008), I used HDDs for a very long time as well. Starting with Mac OS X 10.5 Leopard on this computer, all was fine. It was still fine with OS X 10.8 Mountain Lion, but coming to OS X 10.9 Mavericks, loading something from the HDD became cumbersome (tested with System Preferences which took 30(!) seconds to show up after the system was started). Once started and closed, it re-opened fast (due to it still being in inactive memory or cache). The same with SWTOR under Windows on the very same computer. Using the HDD it took some time to load the game and/or planets. – Phoenix Dec 16 '15 at 09:13
  • I'm a little surprised that the lack of an SSD is making it almost un-usable. Is this standard? Is there anything I can do to improve the performance without spending £100 more on a laptop that is only 3 years old? – Fraser Dec 16 '15 at 12:00
  • You can try clearing caches. You typically find them inside ~/Library/Caches of each user. You can also try to back up all your data (e.g. Time Machine) and reinstall OS X entirely (this is to verify that upgrading to newer OSs did not leave undesired settings in the background. For the long haul I guess that you will not get around spending a bit more and get an SDD. I did so myself eventually. While dissatisfied to spend money as well, I am satisfied with the results. If you buy a non-Apple SSD drive, you want to check about trim to optimize it. Otherwise you may wear it down too fast. – Phoenix Dec 16 '15 at 12:15
  • It's been a month since I asked this but I have replaced the HDD with a new SSD. This has made it feel like a new machine and sped it up hugely. – Fraser Jan 18 '16 at 14:37
  • So I will add my comments (sort of) as an answer. – Phoenix Jan 18 '16 at 17:56

1 Answers1

0

Starting with OS X 10.9 it appears that OS X relies heavily on one having an SSD. Since apps, which have been run once after startup, when relaunching them, they are mainly started off inactive memory/cache and therefore are faster the second time you start them. This is in line with your statement that once they are loaded, they work fine.

As a comparison, in my Mac Pro (Early 2008), I used conventional HDDs for a very long time as well. The computer originally came with Mac OS X 10.5 Leopard, which purred on this machine. All following big cats also purred away without a problem at all.

However, with the naming convention change of OS X 10.9 Mavericks, loading something from the HDD became cumbersome along with it (tested with System Preferences which took 30(!) seconds to show up after the system was started). Once started and closed, it re-opened fast (due to it still being in inactive memory or cache).

The same could be seen later with "Star Wars: The Old Republic" under Windows on the very same computer. Using the HDD it took some time to load the game and/or planets.

While you can try things like clearing caches (which you can find at ~/Library/Caches), or back up all your data (e.g. using Time Machine) and reinstall OS X entirely (to verify that upgrading to newer OSs did not leave undesired settings), for the long haul I guess that you will not get around spending a bit more and get an SDD. I did so myself eventually.

While dissatisfied to spend money as well, I am very satisfied with the results.

IMPORTANT: If you buy a non-Apple SSD drive, you want to check about trim to optimize it. Otherwise you may wear it down too fast and spend even more money in buying a new one earlier.

Phoenix
  • 1,475